Free appointment
Call 24/7

02 8815 8167

Our criminal lawyers are experts at raising the defence of claim of right. Claim of right is a complete defence to stealing (larceny). It also includes any offence that involves stealing as an element, for example robbery. 

What is a claim of right?

You will have a claim of right where you possess a genuine belief that you have a bona fide claim of right to certain money or property. If you believed you were entitled to take the money or property, it does not matter that you did not believe you were entitled to take it in the manner you did.

What is the legal test for claim of right?

The legal principles relating to the defence of claim of right are:

  1. The claim of right must be one that involves a belief as to the right to the property or money in the hands of another.
  2. The claim must be genuinely and honestly held — whether it was well founded in fact or law or not.
  3. While the belief does not have to be reasonable a colourable pretence is insufficient.
  4. The belief must be one of a legal entitlement to the property and not simply a moral entitlement.
  5. The existence of such a claim when genuinely held, may constitute an answer to a crime in which the means used to take the property involved an assault or the use of arms.  The relevant issue being whether the accused had a genuine belief in a legal right to the property rather than a belief in a legal right to employ the means in question to recover it.
  6. The claim of right is not confined to the specific property or banknotes which were once held by the claimant. This can also extend to cases where what is taken is their equivalent in value. That may be qualified when the property is taken ostensibly under a claim of right to hold them by way of safekeeping or as security for a loan, yet the actual intention was to sell them.
  7. The claim of right must extend to the entirety of the property or money taken. Such a claim does not provide any answer where the property or money taken intentionally goes beyond that to which the bona fide claim attaches.
  8. In the case of an Accused is charged as an accessory, what is relevant is the existence of a bona fide claim in the principal offender or offenders. There can be no accessorial liability unless there has in fact been a foundational knowing of the essential facts which made what was done a crime. And, unless the person who is charged as an accessory intentionally aided, abetted, counselled or procured those acts.

Reasonable doubt 

When you raise a claim of right the police must negative the claim of right beyond reasonable doubt.

Testimonials

Joe Correy and his team were amazing. They guided us through one of the most difficult times of our lives... Read the review here

Rebecca Molloy
7/29/2021

Steven Mercael customised my defence to suit my unique situation and who I am as a person. His communication... Read the review here

Soleil Harper
7/19/2021

“The matter has been withdrawn and dismissed”.Joseph acted swiftly and with precision, a true professional and pleasure to deal with.Highly recommended.

Mitchell Curtis
7/09/2021

After visiting 5 lawyers I have decided to hand over my matter to Joe. He is well organised and helped... Read the review here

Irangana Dissanayake
7/02/2021

I want to thank the folks at AC Law Group, especially Steven. Absolute legend in helping being detailed, and keeping... Read the review here

Tommy Nguyen
7/02/2021

A great result for my sons complex case which was handled by Steven Mercael. Steven went above and beyond. He... Read the review here

Charlotte Kayyal
7/02/2021

We search for several lawyers and found Joseph Hab of AC Lawgroup to be the best fit for us. He... Read the review here

Elsa A
7/02/2021

Great lawyer. Very professional, well spoken, great at checking up on me. I had a wonderful experience working with Joeseph

Luka Marjanovic
7/02/2021

Thank you to Joseph for the outstanding work he did on my case. Joseph achieved the best outcome possible.... Read the review here

Warren L
6/28/2021

Just love Joe corey he is confident honest understanding he is good with his job the best of the best... Read the review here

Hassan Ibrahim
6/25/2021

Don’t wait.
Get in touch now.

CONTACT US